There’s really much to be said about the pedigree and time invested by those who are experts in their field- the “textbook theorists” as a friend of mine calls them. These folks certainly deserve acclaim and kudos for their accomplishments and dedication and book-learning. Such credibility doesn’t come without a real investment of blood, sweat and tears in the school of hard knocks.

Often for years and years too.

There’s also lots to be said about the outsider, the folk artist and the “self-taught” types. You may know them; these are the bulldogs and the scrappers, those who simply create for the love of it. It’s pure self-expression. And they often really don’t have a choice in the matter.

Who is more authentic and genuine?

Is one more aboveboard than the other?

Is either more committed to their pursuit of their art?

A good friend of mine recently told me about his experience in a writing “critique” group. A more wisened person, a man of lofty acclaim and with the education and experience and track-record too, at first dismissed and then ripped him apart for his flaws and his “grandstanding” (that’s what he said), and his apparent know-nothingness and agenda or something (yup said that too). This man, a person where the waters parted when he entered a room by the way, quoted folks from days-gone-past, compared him to them, and went on and on (he said) about how he was emulating others, and not successfully mind you. My friend was taken-aback certainly, but at the time took it like a champ. Just responded with what he believed was the appropriate awe and respect.

My friend knows nothing of anyone else and lays no claim to that.

Does this experience compromise his art?  He’s only creating what’s coming out of him. I know him well so know this is the case. Will this lashing affect his muse? He’s really not considering anything when he creates, and most definitely wouldn’t even be capable of conforming to anybody else. What is art anyway? Is it a tipping of the hat to those who’ve come before, an adherence to a style or a method? Or is it the bonafide effort to communicate an intent and a personal creativity, with authenticity.  The jury will always be out and “society” will always bow to those who are well-educated and schooled. Really in any field; human nature it seems. It must be an envy thing or something, or people need to walk around with a medal pinned to their chest or a label taped to their forehead to be heard or esteemed and recognized and identified.

By the way, this critic in question hasn’t produced anything of his own in a long, LONG time.

So the question’s an open one: what is art, who is art? While I personally have an opinion, I don’t wear a medal so who the hell would even listen?

Gosh, just imagine if I did…


9 thoughts on “WHAT IS ART?

  1. That guy in the writers group sounds like a right Arsehole – I would of put him in his place missing a pint of blood and a few teeth. 😉

    Metaphorically speaking.

    Also, “If “society” will always bow to those who are well-educated and schooled” why aren’t more people worshipping at me feet?!?

    So, Which are you Pete Armretta? Schooled or a Pitbull?

  2. “society” will always bow to those who are well-educated and schooled.” – so annoying that this is the case in many situations. I am completely self taught and I quit my second study to pursue what I really love to do. Meaning I don’t have an Art degree ( I do have a degree in Human Resources and studied Sociology) and getting a fund is difficult as having a piece of paper usually is one of the agreements. Doesn’t stop me from trying. Seeing what I actually did and what I’m still doing should count for something right? We shall see. A piece of paper can make things easier, but in the end many other factors determine if you are going to be successful in your field. ^_^

    Great one!

    • I admire the self-taught, well not only because it’s me, but because it shows a passion and drive that often the “schooled” folks don’t have. I know some life-long writers i.e. english majors who to me think of writing as a “job”. To me it’s anything but. I too bailed out of regular life to pursue what I’m doing now and wouldn’t have it any other way!

      My writing speaks for me (for better or worse), not some piece of paper or memories of work done years and years ago.

      Thanks for reading, I appreciate you taking the time.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s